When an American or European company establishes a subsidiary in India, the obvious way to fund it is through equity. But equity is not the only choice. In many circumstances, the parent company (or another overseas lender) can lend money to the Indian business through India’s External Commercial Borrowing framework.
An External Commercial Borrowing, usually called an ECB, is essentially a commercial loan raised by an eligible Indian entity from a recognized lender outside India. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) regulates these transactions under India’s foreign-exchange laws.
For foreign companies expanding in India, ECB can be an important financing tool, but it needs to be structured correctly from the beginning.
Why Use an ECB?
Consider a U.S. manufacturer establishing an Indian subsidiary. The subsidiary needs $5 million for manufacturing equipment, factory improvements and other expansion costs.
The U.S. parent could invest another $5 million as equity. Alternatively, depending on the circumstances, some or all of the funding might be provided as an intercompany loan.
That distinction matters. Equity becomes permanent capital of the Indian company and generally comes back to the parent through dividends, a share sale, capital reduction or liquidation. A loan creates a contractual obligation under which the Indian company pays interest and ultimately repays principal.
ECB can therefore provide greater flexibility in the capital structure of an Indian subsidiary.
Who Can Borrow and Who Can Lend?
The RBI’s ECB framework is considerably broader today than it was in earlier years. As a general rule, Indian entities eligible to receive Foreign Direct Investment can also be eligible ECB borrowers, subject to the detailed requirements of the regulations.
The overseas lender must also qualify as a recognized lender. For multinational companies, an important possibility is borrowing from a foreign parent or other qualifying foreign equity holder. International banks and certain other overseas financial institutions can also be lenders.
An ECB can be denominated in a freely convertible foreign currency, such as U.S. dollars, or in Indian rupees.
Currency Risk Can Change the Economics
This is one of the most important considerations for a foreign parent.
Suppose an Indian subsidiary borrows $5 million from its U.S. parent. Its revenues are primarily in rupees, but the debt is in dollars. If the rupee depreciates substantially during the life of the loan, the subsidiary will need more rupees to repay the same $5 million.
A seemingly inexpensive dollar loan can consequently become considerably more expensive.
Companies should evaluate the interest rate and foreign-exchange exposure together rather than simply comparing an overseas interest rate with the rate offered by an Indian bank. Hedging may be appropriate and, in some situations, regulatory hedging requirements can apply.
An INR-denominated ECB shifts the currency equation because the debt itself is denominated in rupees.
There Are Rules About Maturity and Use of the Money
ECB is not simply an unrestricted transfer of money from a foreign parent to its Indian subsidiary.
RBI rules prescribe parameters including minimum average maturity, recognized lenders, permitted end uses and other conditions. The standard minimum average maturity has generally been three years, although different requirements can apply depending upon the borrower, lender, amount and intended use.
Companies also need to pay particular attention to what the borrowed money will finance.
Certain uses, including working capital, general corporate purposes and repayment of rupee loans, can be permitted only when specified ECB conditions are satisfied. Other transactions fall within the framework’s negative list or require different treatment.
For a foreign company financing a new Indian factory, machinery or expansion, the proposed use of proceeds should therefore be mapped against the ECB regulations before the loan agreement is finalized.
Don’t Wire the Money First and Complete the Paperwork Later
ECB also carries reporting and banking requirements.
The Indian borrower normally works through an Authorized Dealer Category-I bank (typically the Indian bank handling the company’s foreign-exchange transactions). The borrowing must be documented and the required RBI reporting and loan registration procedures completed. Ongoing reporting obligations continue after the loan has been established.
This is an area where coordination between the parent company’s finance team, Indian management, the Indian bank, tax advisers and legal counsel is particularly important.
Interest payments also have Indian tax implications, including potential withholding tax, and the India tax treaty with the lender’s country may affect the ultimate tax treatment.
Equity, ECB or Indian Bank Financing?
There is no universally correct answer.
A new Indian subsidiary with little revenue may need substantial equity initially. A more established subsidiary with predictable cash flow might benefit from a combination of equity and debt. Local Indian borrowing eliminates some cross-border complications and may avoid foreign-currency exposure, but its interest cost and collateral requirements may differ significantly.
For many multinational companies, the best solution is a carefully designed combination.
The important point is to decide how the Indian business will be financed while designing the subsidiary, rather than several months later when it suddenly needs cash. Capital structure, taxes, currency exposure, cash repatriation and RBI compliance are interconnected. Getting those decisions right at the beginning can make financing the Indian operation considerably easier as the business grows.